Signal Integrity Issues and Countermeasures

An ancient Chinese proverb holds that when we’re satisfied, our desires tend to grow, and this notion resonates in the realm of electronics. In the 20th century, mobile phones served a single purpose – making calls. However, they have since evolved into multi-functional devices, encompassing communication, multimedia, photography, and more.

With users expecting enhanced performance from their devices, a plethora of high-speed digital systems are now under development. Consequently, system data rates, clock frequencies, and circuit densities are on the rise. In this dynamic landscape, high-speed digital systems bring forth unique challenges, leading to signal integrity issues. These issues, stemming from fast-slope transients and soaring operating frequencies, result in distinct behaviors in cables, interconnects, boards, and chips compared to their low-speed counterparts. This variance can lead to problems such as signal distortion and timing errors.

In this TechSparks article, we delve into signal integrity concerns, examining their origins and exploring effective mitigation strategies.

Impact of Signal Integrity Issues on PCB

Signal Reflection Issues

In electrical circuits, the conveyance of electrical signals relies on transmission lines. These lines are meticulously designed with specific electrical properties to regulate the pace of signal transmission, with one crucial characteristic being the characteristic impedance—a consistent value typically measured in ohms (Ω). The two terminations of the transmission line connect to the source and the load, each with their own characteristic impedances, namely the source impedance and the load impedance. However, when these impedances fail to align with the characteristic impedance of the transmission line, a dilemma known as signal reflection emerges.

In the transmission of signals, this mismatch in impedances gives rise to signal reflection issues. This essentially means that a portion of the signal dispatched by the source reaches the load as intended, while another portion rebounds back to the signal source, giving rise to complications in signal integrity. The fallout from signal reflection problems manifests as signal waveform anomalies like overshoots and undershoots, along with a phenomenon referred to as ringing.

To elaborate, when a signal experiences a sudden transition or edge shift—such as an abrupt shift from a low level to a high one, or vice versa—the signal’s voltage momentarily exceeds the anticipated power level or reference ground level. Typically, this surplus manifests as an instantaneous peak and can take the form of either a positive overshoot (surpassing the power level) or a negative overshoot (going below the reference ground level), often termed a downshoot. This leads to the occurrence of periodic oscillations in the signal waveform at specific intervals, resulting from multiple reflections and interference effects. This phenomenon translates into the presence of multiple peaks and valleys in the signal over time.

Ringing in Signal Integrity

Signal Crosstalk Issues

Intrusion of unwanted noise interference from adjacent signal lines in a circuit is termed crosstalk. This phenomenon, if left unaddressed, can culminate in signal integrity issues, ultimately degrading the quality of transmission. The fundamental cause of crosstalk can be attributed to coupling effects, notably capacitance and inductance, which facilitate the propagation of electromagnetic energy from one line to another.

Capacitive coupling, often referred to as capacitive crosstalk, arises from the electric field’s influence on neighboring lines, giving rise to voltage interference issues. On the other hand, inductive coupling, known as inductive crosstalk, occurs when electromagnetic energy, through the magnetic field, affects nearby lines, resulting in disruptions to the flow of current.

The emergence and severity of crosstalk are contingent on several variables, including the length of alignment, spacing between lines, and the state of the reference ground plane on the PCB, typically composed of copper. Longer alignments, narrower spacing, and less-than-ideal ground planes can all contribute to crosstalk complications, potentially leading to incomplete signal transmission.

Signal Delays and Timing Errors

Signal transmission speed is intricately linked to the characteristics of the wire, encompassing both its material and geometry. When the time it takes for an electrical signal to traverse from the transmitter to the receiver veers away from the anticipated value, it often culminates in a timing error. This discrepancy translates into a misalignment between the signal’s arrival time and the desired timing. The ultimate consequence is a disruption in the functionality of logic circuits, rendering them incapable of performing as intended.

7 Steps to Resolve Signal Integrity Issues

Step 1: Preliminary Design Preparations

Effective pre-design preparations and strategic planning lay the foundation for a successful electronic system or circuit board design. These preparations encompass the following crucial steps:

  1. Begin by precisely determining the requirements and specifications that outline the intended circuit’s function and performance criteria. These may include factors like frequency, bandwidth, timing, and other essential parameters.
  2. Identify the most suitable components and suppliers or brands that align with your project’s requirements. Ensuring a proper fit between components and your design objectives is paramount.
  3. Select the appropriate signal integrity analysis tools, such as SPICE, HSPICE, or IBIS, to facilitate the simulation and analysis of signal characteristics. This includes evaluating signal ups and downs, rise times, fall times, and more.
  4. Devise a comprehensive plan for power distribution while implementing efficient grounding strategies. This approach aims to minimize ground return path resistance, contributing to improved signal integrity.
  5. Perform thorough timing analysis to ascertain that signals reach their intended destinations within the specified clock period. Timing precision is critical for the proper functioning of your circuit.

These pre-design preparations serve as a valuable guide for establishing design guidelines, making informed component choices, and selecting production processes that reduce the likelihood of significant signal integrity issues in real-world applications. Additionally, they contribute to cost-effective production practices.

Step 2: Partnering with the Right Manufacturer

In B2B practices, selecting the ideal PCB manufacturer stands as a pivotal decision when taking charge of your project. Manufacturing partnerships in this arena tend to be long-term commitments, and switching suppliers is often neither practical nor conducive to project stability, especially if your project evolves over time. Hence, it’s imperative to thoroughly assess manufacturing-related considerations before finalizing this critical relationship.

To ensure a harmonious match, scrutinize the following manufacturing aspects: Manufacturing Tolerances, Substrate Insulation Constants, Line Width and Spacing Tolerance Range, PCB Thickness, and Impedance Control.

Step 3: Mitigating Crosstalk and Ensuring Impedance Control

The concepts of the two have been explained in the previous content, so how to avoid crosstalk and impedance control?

  • Begin by conducting coupling analysis to ascertain the safe and expected spacing between signal lines.
  • Employ ground planes or shielding techniques to physically isolate sensitive signals from potential sources of noise.
  • Embrace the use of differential signaling, which involves transmitting signals as a pair with opposite polarities. This approach helps offset the impact of external noise, enhancing signal integrity.
  • Carefully choose PCB materials based on project requirements, giving particular attention to the dielectric constants of the materials.
  • In high-speed signal transmission lines, consider using terminating resistors.
  • To maintain signal and power plane continuity throughout the PCB design process, undertake appropriate hierarchical planning.

In practical scenarios where you need to limit crosstalk from clock to data signal nodes to less than 100mV while maintaining parallel signal alignments, you can determine the minimum allowable spacing between signals on specific wiring layers through calculation or simulation. Moreover, if your design involves nodes where impedance is a crucial factor, you may need to allocate specific wiring to one or more layers to achieve the desired impedance characteristics.

Step 4: Identifying Key Nodes

In layout design, nodes serve as connection points or intersections between electronic components, facilitating the transmission of electronic signals or power supply. These nodes can manifest physically as pads or pins between components or logically as intersecting points within a circuit. The key nodes are some positions with special significance, which may include according to different projects:

  • Timing Nodes: These nodes play a pivotal role in determining the performance of a circuit, particularly in high-speed digital applications.
  • Power Nodes: Ensuring a stable power supply to the circuit.
  • Signal Integrity Nodes: Used to transmit high-frequency signals to ensure signal integrity.
  • EMI Sensitive Nodes: These nodes may either emit electromagnetic interference or be susceptible to interference from other components.
  • Thermal Nodes: In high-power circuits, thermal nodes generate significant heat and demand proper thermal management.
  • Secure Nodes: To prevent unauthorized access or data leakage, secure nodes are essential components of the design.

Identifying these critical nodes during the initial design phase is crucial. Subsequent sessions should involve thorough circuit performance analysis, simulation, and testing to ensure optimal functionality. Additionally, for enhanced signal integrity, consider routing all high-speed signal nodes on inner layers while implementing impedance control through dedicated transmission line structures like striplines or differential transmission lines.

Step 5: Technology Selection

Point-to-Point or Multiplexed Transmission? Are the signals output from the PCB or reserved? Time lag and noise margin? The basic rule is to choose the drive technology according to the different projects.

This is like configuring a rise time of 500ps for a 50MHz clock signal. Obviously, this is unreasonable. Instead, you should opt for a faster and more capable solution to ensure the integrity of the clock signal, such as a rate control device designed for high-speed applications.

In today’s landscape, advanced drive technologies like FPGA programmable technology or user-defined ASICs offer significant advantages. These custom or semi-custom devices provide flexibility in choosing drive amplitude and speed. To streamline the design process, especially in the early phases, ensure that your FPGA or ASIC design aligns with project requirements and determine the appropriate output configuration, including pin selection if feasible.

During this design phase, acquiring suitable simulation models from IC suppliers is crucial. To effectively conduct signal integrity simulations, you’ll need access to a signal integrity simulation program along with the relevant simulation models. This ensures that your technology selection aligns with your project’s signal integrity needs.

Step 6: Pre-Wiring Phase

The initial steps in pre-wiring signal integrity planning involve defining crucial input parameters, including drive amplitude, impedance, and tracking speed, as well as potential topology variations such as minimum and maximum lengths, and short lengths. With these parameters established, a comprehensive set of simulations is conducted, covering every possible combination. The goal is to meticulously analyze the results of both timing and signal integrity simulations, ultimately identifying an acceptable range of values.

Following this, the determined operating ranges are translated into routing constraints for the PCB layout. Various software tools can facilitate this preparatory phase, ensuring that routing programs automatically adhere to these constraints. For many users, the timing information gleaned from these simulations holds greater significance than the signal integrity results. This timing data can be leveraged to adjust routing paths, thus optimizing signal timing.

In certain applications, this process serves to identify pins or device placements that are incompatible with the system’s timing requirements. At this juncture, it becomes feasible to pinpoint nodes that necessitate manual wiring or nodes that can forego termination. For programmable devices and ASICs, this phase also presents an opportunity to fine-tune output drivers, either to enhance the overall signal integrity design or to obviate the need for discrete termination devices.

Step 7: Post-Routing Signal Integrity Simulation

In reality, regardless of how meticulously designers work, it’s challenging to guarantee 100% immunity from signal integrity issues after completing the routing phase, even when following PCB design guidelines. To address this concern, simulations serve as a valuable checkpoint. Moreover, simulations provide the flexibility to intentionally adjust or modify design rules, but these changes are typically made for cost-efficiency reasons or in response to stringent routing demands.

Ensuring Signal Integrity Design Rules

  • Managing multiple circuit elements to execute simultaneous switching operations in response to a clock signal while constraining the rate of current and voltage rise and fall. Striking the right balance in edge rates to achieve the lowest yet acceptable levels.
  • Opting for differential signals in high-output function blocks to enhance performance.
  • Implementing termination of passive components on the transmission line to attain impedance matching between the transmission line and the load.
  • Minimizing the length of parallel wiring alignments.
  • Steering clear of component placement at I/O interconnect interfaces and other susceptible areas prone to interference and coupling.
  • Reducing the distance between signal alignments and the reference plane.
  • Lowering alignment impedance and signal drive levels when necessary.
  • Incorporating termination matching circuits or components as required.
  • Avoiding parallel routing of alignments and ensuring adequate spacing between them.

More content you may be interested in

A Comprehensive Guide to PCB Reverse Engineering
PCB Reverse Engineering Guide

PCB reverse engineering, also known as cloning or copy, is essentially the process of extracting the original information from electronic products’ circuit boards through various

microvia
What is Microvia in PCB?

Microvias are small holes in PCBs facilitating high-density interconnections. Their reliability is challenged by complex thermo-mechanical environments, requiring careful design and manufacturing. Techniques like mechanical

tented vias
Tented Vias in PCB

The article emphasizes the significance of tenting PCB vias to shield them from external factors, enhancing signal integrity and assembly processes, particularly in high-speed and

buried via hole
What Are Buried Vias in PCB and Their Purpose

Buried vias enhance signal efficiency in multilayer PCBs, crucial for high-density interconnects. Despite added costs, they play a vital role in advanced electronic devices, optimizing

Scroll to Top